(Bech)Delving into Fun Home's Literary References
Throughout Fun Home, Bechdel makes multiple notable literary references, even stating that her "parents are most real to [her] in fictional terms" (67). Through her childhood as the daughter of two English teachers, and her literary explorations throughout her life, Bechdel has been exposed to a plethora of prominent works of literature. These analogies are used frequently in Fun Home. Some notable analogies that will be discussed include the story of Daedalus and Icarus and Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby.
The first analogy, appearing a mere two pages into the book, is about the story of Daedalus and Icarus. In the myth, Daedalus is a talented craftsman and the father of Icarus; to allow himself and his son Icarus to fly out of prison, he builds two pairs of wings. Although Daedalus warns Icarus not to fly too close to the sun, Icarus disregards his father's warnings and his wings melt. The story concludes with Icarus' fall and subsequent death. Bruce is compared to both Daedalus and Icarus in Fun Home. Bechdel's father is Daedalus in the sense that he is a devoted craftsman could "spin garbage ... into gold" (6). Bechdel notes that her father's craftsmanship was an effort to create a perfect facade for their family: instead of viewing his family as human, Bruce saw them as part of the perfect artwork that is Fun Home. Each ill-placed vase was an imperfection in the artwork for him. Meanwhile, Bruce is also viewed as Icarus, in the sense that his failure led to his death. Here, the "fall" most likely represents the collapsing of his artwork. The world that he has constructed so painstakingly falls apart seemingly instantaneously as his sexual preference is exposed, and his marriage is torn apart. Bechdel seems to be implying that the shallowness of Bruce's construction (i.e., lack of foundation) led to her father's sudden fall. While Icarus literally fell to his death, Bruce's cause of death is unclear; however, Alison chooses to believe that he committed suicide in order to maintain her connection with him.
The second literary reference is Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, another tale closely related to the theme of superficiality and embellishment. The parallels drawn between Fun Home and The Great Gatsby are more related to Bruce's marriage. One of the reasons Bechdel is so drawn to this book is that Fitzgerald, the author of The Great Gatsby, lived three days longer than her father. In The Great Gatsby, Jay Gatsby, the main character, is a rich man who yearns to be reunited with his old love from his days of poverty, but to no avail. The main connection here is that Gatsby is a man who, on the outside, has everything: he has a mansion and all the luxuries imaginable in his hands. However, he is unable to reach his true dreams past the mask of wealth that he wears, and, in the end, dries tragically. The same goes with Bruce, who, on the surface, has a perfect family and the most beautiful house in the neighborhood. However, his deepest desires of exploring his homosexuality openly are prohibited by society, and he is forced to keep up his false character. Thus, he looks at Alison, who has had the liberty and environment to freely explore her own sexuality, with admiration and jealousy. In one of the final scenes of the book, where Alison and Bruce ride a car together, Alison brings up how Bruce recommended a book about lesbianism to her. Bruce opens up briefly, explaining that he used to want to be a girl and dated boys in college. However, like Gatsby, Bruce is fearful of his exposure and closes up again, hiding his desires below his facade once again. Despite his successful life on the outside, he misses his old days, where he could freely explore his sexuality before joining the military.
Fun Home contains many more literary references, including Camus' work, and A Portrait of the Lady by Henry James. However, these two books are some of the most prominent examples of Alison listing the parallels between her family dynamics and the lives of these fictional characters. Bruce's life and sexuality is explored thoroughly in Fun Home, and Bechdel seemingly puts a lot of emphasis on deciphering each memory that she shares with her father. Her desperation to connect to her father leads her to make multiple (valid) literary references. Interestingly, however, her father's abrupt death leaves ample room for interpretation. Alison's analysis of Bruce through works of fiction is, however, undoubtedly robust.
I like your choice of title and the connections you make between The Great Gatsby and Fun Home. Indeed Jay Gatsby and Bruce seem quite similar, and it's interesting that while they're both seemingly successful men who both have emotional struggles, in Bruce's case Alison seems to augment this feeling of longing.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoy the analysis literary references in Fun Home, such as how you connect Bruce to both Daedalus and Icarus. The idea that his downfall is tied to the fragility of the world he built adds depth to his character and highlights the tragedy of his life. your comparison between Bruce and Gatsby. Nice Blog!
ReplyDeleteTo REALLY teach this book properly, it would need to be the only book on the syllabus, and we'd need to read all these other texts in order to fully grasp the uses Bechdel is making of them. We could take a spin through Greek mythology but ALSO James Joyce, whose words form the title of the first chapter and whose magnum opus _Ulysses_ is one key intertext in the final chapter. We'd need to read Fitzgerald (his letters and biography in addition to _Gatsby_), along with Henry James, Oscar Wilde, Marcel Proust, and a dozen or so other books and authors that are cited.
ReplyDeleteHappily, we CAN make some sense of these allusions without having read the books, as Bechdel usually offers some context for readers to understand--she tells us what we need to know about Henry James's _Portrait of a Lady_ to grasp why she's suggesting some parallels between her mother in Europe and Isabel Archer, the American "lady" in Europe in that novel. She gives you a good deal to go on with _The Importance of Being Earnest_, too, but knowing that play as I do, I also keep thinking of how you're missing some of the nuance of the allusions--when you know the scenes being rehearsed in some of those frames, you'll see even further and deeper connections to the surrounding text.
This is surely among the most complex, multilayered, and *literary* graphic novels ever made. You really do need a Ph.D. in literature to fully understand it.
I really like the comparison between Fun Home and the Icarus myth. I found your analysis of the cases in which Bruce represented both Icarus and Daedalus to be very interesting. I think it adds a lot of depth to his desperation that can only be described by combining the two figures.
ReplyDeleteHi, I really liked how you showed that literature helps Alison make sense of her relationship with her father. Your comparison of Bruce to both Daedalus and Icarus was a strong way to show how complicated he is. The connection to The Great Gatsby was also really insightful, especially how Bruce and Gatsby both live behind carefully built facades. Great analysis!
ReplyDelete