Dana's Arm

Octavia E. Butler's Kindred begins with Dana admitting that she had "lost [her] arm on [her] last trip home. [Her] left arm" (9). Interestingly, the book employs a sort of in media res tactic, immersing the reader in the physical cost of Dana's time travel. In fact, the novel essentially begins and ends with the arm; it's clear that Butler regards it as an important symbol for Kindred's message. 

On the surface level, Butler asserts at the very beginning of the novel that Kindred isn't a sci-fi adventure story. Instead, it's closer to a horror trope, a story where the journey permanently takes a part of Dana away with her. In a way, Butler directly contrasts it to the classic Hero's Journey, where the protagonist returns with newfound wisdom. The book must be taken seriously, as there's no "reset" button to pretend that the loss of her arm never happened—just like slavery. 

During the actual moment of the loss, just after she stabs Rufus to prevent him from raping her, Dana confesses that "something harder and stronger than Rufus's hand clamped down on [her] arm, squeezing it, stiffening it, pressing into it—painlessly at first—melting into it like molten lead" (260-61). The message of this seems to be that the past itself has a grip on her: even as Rufus dies, the systematic oppression that slavery is refuses to let go of Black Americans. Even as Dana escapes to her freedom, Rufus—and the system of slavery that he stands for—takes away a part of Dana. A part of her body is left behind in Maryland, seemingly preventing her complete liberation. 

In fact, this is confirmed by the author herself. Butler explains that "I couldn't really let her come all the way back. I couldn't let her return to what she was, I couldn't let her come back whole and that, I think, really symbolizes her not coming back whole. Antebellum slavery didn't leave people quite whole" (267).

Back home, Dana still doesn't understand what exactly has happened to her. As she discovers the list of slaves at the present-day Maryland farm, she reflects on her experiences. Here, the arm seems to stand for her generational trauma—just as how slavery has scarred the social dynamics of modern America, Dana is forced to relearn how to navigate the world, now with the impacts of slavery deeply engraved into her mind.

Comments

  1. Brianna GibsonNovember 19, 2025 at 10:47 AM

    Hi Jay, I like your take on the story behind Dana's arm. I totally understand the idea that the past still has a grip on her, even though Rufus is no longer living. Slavery will always be something that existed, and it will always have that sense of a grip on Black Americans, more so during that time specifically. Nice Job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. leoNovember 24, 2025 at 11:34 PM

    I really like the concept of an inverse Hero's Journey, where instead of gaining something, the protagonist loses something. However, I think you could also consider this a tradeoff with a positive net value. In exchange for her arm, Dana secures her survival in the present, which is arguably more important than a limb. However, was Dana actually necessary for Rufus to survive, or would history have progressed the same way if Dana never went back in time?

    ReplyDelete
  3. ElliotthegreatDecember 1, 2025 at 3:03 PM

    Hi JW Pak, I like how you make a symbolic meaning behind Dana's arm considering it to be the past, and while she won't have to go through the problem of the past as it is gone, it still leaved scars on her physically (which is the main part of this blog) with her arm being gone and constantly reminding her of the events, but also psychologically as she chose to adopt the ideas of the typical slave in order to stay alive. Great Job!

    ReplyDelete
  4. MitchellDecember 3, 2025 at 11:56 AM

    It would be really interesting to explore the idea of _Kindred_ as following a hero's journey archetype--talk about being taken from the familiar world and thrust into "adventure"! And the fact that the "call to adventure" is *involuntary* also reflects the unique horrors of this particular historical tourism, as Dana's "kidnapping" from the present to the past is completely outside her control or agency. The idea that she DOES return with wisdom and insight (and the "boon" might also include the fact that she has ensured her family's survival, too) is complicated by the lost arm, but that lost arm (and the death of Rufus, the "ultimate test") also signifies that she has fully returned to the present ("my last trip home")--so we have a decisive "homecoming." Not a bad idea for an essay, if anyone is interested in pursuing it!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Barely Holden On

J.D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye features Holden Caulfield as its protagonist. From the moment of his expulsion from Pencey, Holden spirals into a downward mental decline. One of his most defining traits is his willingness to become a martyr—sacrificing himself to uphold his values and idolizing self-destruction as a means of achieving moral victory. The first instance of this is his fight with Stradlater. Despite Stradlater practically begging Holden to stop calling him a “phony” and a “moron,” Holden persists, refusing to back down even when he is physically harmed. Holden is furious that Stradlater—a shallow and insincere figure—does not appreciate Jane Gallagher the way he does. While Holden treasures small, intimate details about Jane, such as how she keeps her kings in the back row when playing checkers, Stradlater sees her as just another conquest in the prep school dating scene. This infuriates Holden, leading him to provoke Stradlater despite knowing he will be overpower...
Read more

Tayloring Jason to Society: In The Pursuit of a True Identity

 During the chapter Goose Fair, Jason enters the Hall of Mirrors, in which he views multiple reflections of himself, each representing a different aspect of his mind. Jason says that the mirrors in the room "melted [him] into self-mutants" (248). This scene can be viewed as a crucial part of his coming-of-age in which he has an internal conversation: after this scene, Jason tears apart his bully's calculator and mocks him in front of the whole class. The internal conversation that Jason has in the Hall of Mirrors convinces Jason to merge his external and internal selves into his true self.  In the first mirror, he sees an "African tribesman with a neck giraffed by iron rings" in his reflection. The man asks, "Can a person change ... into another person" (249)? He sees this reflection as a representation of the self-criticism he has developed toward his fake identity in BSG. From the start, he is fixated on his external representation in society, planni...
Read more

The Sagging Weight of Dad's BBQ

 In Sag Harbor , Ben's interactions with his father characterize his family dynamics and, in part, explains Elena's self-distancing from Ben's family. His father is frequently described as destructive: for instance, Ben fears the sound of the alcohol cabinet opening, implying that domestic violence is frequent.  Throughout the book, the father is shown as a figure in the post-civil rights movement generation: he lives by the teachings of DuBois and feels a strong racial pride as an African-American man. More precisely, most of the Sag adults feel this pride-- DuBois was one of the "certain names ... [with] an emanation or halo" (18). In fact, even Ben reports being blown away by DuBois' teachings of double-consciousness during his college years (18). However, his dad is special in that this pride often comes at the cost of his family and influences Ben's actions. The first example of his father's violence is when Ben is hit for not retaliating against ...
Read more